Who’s Who in the Cast
Read the cast and crew biographies of the alumni who are featured in this article.
Meet Kenyon’s new crop of stage stars.
Story by Molly Vogel ‘00 | Photo by Chris Sorensen
It begins with Aristotle. As any drama major who took “Introduction to the Theater” could tell you, he believed that a play should have a beginning, middle and end, with actions that follow a logical sequence. In the entry-level course better known as “Baby Drama,” students internalize this structure, and other elements of his “Poetics,” through playwriting, acting, directing and study, until the final denouement of graduation, when they leave to pursue careers in theater that really have no set structure at all.
Kenyon has a long, proud drama history. Of course, actor Paul Newman ’49 H’61 must be mentioned, along with Allison Janney ’82 H’00, Josh Radnor ’96 H’24 and teacher-to-the-stars Ted Walch ’63.
Shakespeare was right: what’s past really is prologue. Today, many new drama alumni appear in Playbills.
Knud Adams ’09 was nominated for a Tony Award for directing. Will Dagger ’10 starred on Broadway (alongside George Clooney). “All Nighter” by Natalie Margolin ’14 ran off-Broadway for 12 weeks. Will Arbery ’11 was a Pulitzer Prize finalist for playwriting. Beth Hyland ’13 won the Kennedy Center’s Mark Twain Award for Comic Playwriting (twice). Japhet Balaban ’09 and Christopher James Stevens ’17 appeared in “Leopoldstadt” together on Broadway. Adam Petherbridge ’08 starred in more than 1,200 performances of “The Play that Goes Wrong” on-tour and off-Broadway.
At Kenyon, these drama and film majors developed broad theater skills and connections that keep them (mostly) employed in theater. (Many alumni are forging careers on screens as well — Jonathan Tazewell ’84 P’15, the Thomas S. Turgeon Professor of Drama and Film, helped introduce the film major in 2011 — but for this story, the play’s the thing.)
Wendy MacLeod ’81 P’15,’17 taught drama at Kenyon for over three decades before her retirement as the James E. Michael Playwright-in-Residence this year. Kenyon students, she says, learn to become generalists in a department that demystifies the artistic process and demonstrates that there is a craft that can be learned. “It teaches playmakers to ask questions of a given text, whether you’re acting in it, directing it, designing it or writing it.
“Too many people think that characters having a conversation is the same thing as a play. It is not. Too many people think that acting is about illustrating emotion when it is about eliciting emotion. A conservatory risks narrowing your focus, whereas a liberal arts education widens it.
Read the cast and crew biographies of the alumni who are featured in this article.
Julia Greer ’15, who starred in two sold-out runs of the one-woman show “Big Feelings” by Ryan Drake ’14 this year at the Cell Theatre in New York, can attest to this idea. She likes to tell a story about how “Baby Drama” equipped her to overcome literal Disney villains. In 2016, she was producing her very first play, “Power of Punctuation,” by and starring Natalie Margolin, in a tiny rented theater on 45th Street. One day she arrived to find a note that some Disney folks had redone all the set lighting as part of an earlier light lab. “We had a show in an hour, and I was like, ‘I know how to refocus lights, I can get up on a ladder’,” Greer says.
Japhet Balaban wrapped a month-long run in “Eureka Day” this June at the Huntington Theatre in Boston. “The thing about Kenyon that I appreciate so much was that it made me do everything in addition to acting,” he says.
“Taking a lighting design class was really incredible. I found I had to go elsewhere to get a voice lesson, or something that wasn’t Aristotle,” — he’s half-joking — “but what Kenyon gave me was a big sense of how the script works and how everything works together.”
In a steady theater career that nevertheless is inherently inconsistent, Balaban also credits Kenyon with preparing him to approach every job as a learning experience. This helps him continue to hone his craft and, also, not go totally bonkers when he can’t know what’s coming next. “What’s exciting is that I’m still learning and still figuring it out,” he says, sounding genuinely excited.
“What I love about theater is that we’re all building it together. I love the rehearsal room, and I love discovering and playing and learning how to fail, and having fun failing, and getting comfortable being bad and finding out how to be more truthful.”
And then, the performance. “Sometimes, there’s a moment where you can hear the AC turn on because everyone’s so quiet.”
Last year, Balaban took part in a workshop with Will Dagger, two Kenyon people just playing around again in the theater. “There was a lot of ‘let’s just do it’-kind-of energy at Kenyon,” Dagger recalls, saying it was vital preparation for making it in New York.
Here we must pause for George Clooney, Dagger’s recent costar in “Good Night and Good Luck,” which ran for 99 performances last year, including previews, and made gobs of money and headlines. “At that time, I was like, ‘I don’t think this is actually happening, right?’” Dagger says.
“There’s just a way that he moves through the world that is totally different. And when you’re flying in a V with him, it’s a surreal feeling,” he says, recalling that the idea and plan to air the production live for one night on CNN seemingly came together in five hours after a couple of Clooney phone calls.
This, of course, is not typical. Because practically nobody has Clooney pull, many Kenyon people, including Dagger, have formed their own theater companies to create their own sandboxes, often working with Kenyon people, as Greer also did with Emma Miller ’15 (see sidebar).
The first production Greer and Miller mounted through their company, The Hearth, was “For Annie” by Beth Hyland. “When people in theater find out you went to Kenyon, they say, ‘There’s so many of you guys, what was happening there?’” Hyland says.
She blames Aristotle.
“I refer to it, like, very lovingly and respectfully, as Kenyon’s playwriting program is Aristotelian brainwashing — it is hardcore.”
She credits this taught internalizing of structure with giving shape to otherwise unmolded exuberance. “When you’re a young artist, what you get for free is your energy and your passion and your desire to experiment and to push and to change and innovate. What tends to be lacking, because you are young, is craft.
“I really think Aristotle is the secret sauce,” Hyland says.
Ben Viccellio ’98, associate professor of drama and film, validates this. “By the time a drama major graduates four years later, it is completely understandable if they never want to hear the name ‘Aristotle’ again because we just pound it for four years.”
This focus on fundamentals, he says, teaches Kenyon students to put their focus on the audiences, rather than themselves. “In other words, ask the questions, don’t give the answers,” he says.
“In a lot of ways, storytelling is just an exercise in creating expectations for an audience and then potentially subverting those expectations in interesting, entertaining ways. But in order to do that, you’ve got to know how to create those expectations.”
Viccellio remembers learning these same lessons from the late legendary drama professors Tom Turgeon H’08 P’89,’93 GP’21,’23 and Harlene Marley H’05, recognized on campus with an endowed position and black box theater, respectively. They also taught — then taught alongside —Tazewell and MacLeod, who went on to teach Viccellio, who then instructed Hyland and her peers after he returned to Kenyon in 2009. “To this day, if I’m directing a show, if I’m performing as an actor in a reading or something, one of the very first questions that occurs to me is: ‘What would Wendy think about this?’”
It is easy to find cycles, circles and connections among Kenyon’s theater community. Ted Walch taught Natalie Margolin at Harvard-Westlake School in Los Angeles, years after he returned to campus to help Paul Newman open the Bolton Theater with “C.C. Pyle and the Bunion Derby,” starring Janney.
Janney is now on Broadway in “Other Desert Cities,” a play that was being workshopped at the Ojai Playwrights Conference in 2010, the year Balaban interned there — and now he’s understudying in the Broadway production. Margolin and Greer also both interned there, and Harrison David Rivers ’04 workshopped his play “Except That It Is God” there this summer, where he met Malcolm James Kutner ’94, vice president of the Ojai board, and his Kenyon classmate Jenn Fishman ’94, now an English teacher at Marquette University who attended as his guest. (Kenyon had its own playwrights conference from 2013 to 2018, with artistic direction by MacLeod.)
Knud Adams also interned at Ojai as a student. He returned in 2020 as a director and, last summer, he directed a conference semi-finalist.
In his first few weeks at Kenyon, despite having no experience, Adams talked his way into directing a production of “The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abridged),” staged by Renegade Theater, a first-year company. Balaban was among the stars, and they packed the old black box theater in the village. “The rehearsal process was really joyful and playful and creative. None of us really knew what we were doing. People liked it, and I just fell in love.”
He’s been directing ever since on both coasts, including plays by Gracie Gardner ’13 (see sidebar) and Arbery, and working with Balaban again. In addition to his Tony nomination last year for “English,” with that play, Adams earned the rare distinction of staging world premieres of back-to-back Pulitzer Prize-winning plays, prompting the L.A. Times to label him “red hot” and “one of the most prized directors of new work in the country.” (The other was “Primary Trust,” which he workshopped at Ojai.)
He credits MacLeod with stoking his enthusiasm in her “Contemporary Theater” class “that sort of blew my mind and taught me what theater could be, whilst also doing the tough job of drilling into us the basics. ...
“I think it’s in my DNA, and it’s this unspoken foundation for how I problem-solve. I’m just constantly surprised by the rareness of that model, and I think it’s a really good one.”
Despite having no fewer than six projects in some stage of development, Rivers acknowledges the profession is anything but steady, in a sentiment echoed by everyone in this story. “Honestly, I feel like I’m still figuring out how to turn playwriting into a career. It truly is a day-to-day, day-by-day endeavor.”
Before leaving Chicago for the gentle embrace of health insurance and paid time to write in grad school at UC San Diego, Hyland worked a series of day jobs for eight years. “I was a nanny. I was a copywriter at Groupon. I was an editor. I was an administrative assistant at a college. I would do that during the day, and then I would rehearse four hours for a different play at night,” all while taking public transit.
Balaban mostly worked in restaurants and bars to pay the bills. His first job was answering the phones at PDT, a speakeasy hidden behind a phone booth inside a hot dog restaurant. Dagger does remote customer service to fill the gaps. Adams had a data entry temp job in which they asked him to don a chicken suit for an ad — this was after he’d been reviewed in the New York Times. Greer captains weddings, running the event logistics in a restaurant venue. “It really feels like all the parts about producing that I like, and it’s over in one night, and it actually pays well,” she says, something that can’t usually be said for theater.
At the same time, this summer Greer was preparing to film a small part in a movie in New York that she wasn’t allowed to talk about, and she had a play lined up in Maine for August. Balaban paused to get married this summer before booking his understudy gig on Broadway. Dagger followed Clooney with an off-Broadway run. Adams’ next show “The Unbelievers” opened off-Broadway in October. After 12 years in New York, Margolin is settled in Los Angeles with several TV projects in development. Hyland was recently in London working on a commissioned musical about the life of the late Italian operatic tenor Luciano Pavarotti, and her play “Baby Shower Katie” will premiere off-Broadway in February.
Hyland is excited to be back in New York. “So many of my Kenyon alumni theater buddies are there that it’s so thrilling. I just saw Ryan Drake and Julia Greer’s play ‘Big Feelings’ on Monday — it was wonderful.”
Her peers’ success may not follow a logical sequence, but is a neat ending fit to please Aristotle.
“There is literally no better feeling than seeing people who you have known for so long, who you met as teenagers, who you have always thought are so special and brilliant — then seeing the world agree.”
Professor of Drama Emerita
Margolin calls MacLeod “life-changing” for her as a student. “I was really falling in love with playwriting, and I remember talking to Wendy at the Village Inn, just one of those great Kenyon moments, where you can have a conversation with a professor in the village that we all share.”
Rivers says he’s most inspired by her longevity. “This is a really tough industry. ... It takes patience and tenacity and a real doggedness to continue in the face of near-constant rejection and seeming scarcity. Whenever I’m feeling discouraged, I look at Wendy’s body of work — ‘The House Of Yes,’ ‘The Water Children,’ ‘Women In Jeopardy,’ ‘Slow Food,’ ‘The Laugh Track!’ I am grateful to have had such a brilliant example of stick-to-itiveness to follow.”
MacLeod says the playwright-in-residence job was a “gift.”
“Very few playwrights make a living in the theater, so one either writes for film and television or teaches. Teaching was my natural bent and felt more meaningful to me. It allowed me to raise a family in a beautiful college town, surrounded by intelligent students and colleagues. It also kept me writing because I was demanding that of my students.”
To read Viccellio’s citation for MacLeod’s honorary doctorate of fine arts presented at Commencement, download the 2026 Commencement program.
Molly (Willow) Vogel ’00 took “Baby Drama” with professors Turgeon and Marley and was completely intimidated by Viccellio in other drama classes.
Knud Adams ’09

Knud Adams is a Tony-nominated, Obie-winning director, based in New York. His world-premiere productions include the consecutive Pulitzer winners “English” and “Primary Trust.” Adams’ shows have been celebrated on “Best of the Year” lists by the Los Angeles Times, New York Times, New York Magazine, New Yorker, and Washington Post. Variety hailed his acclaimed Broadway debut of Sanaz Toossi’s “English” as “one of the best plays of the decade.” Additional world premieres include “Cold War Choir Practice,” “The Aves,” “The Book of Mountains and Seas,” “I’m Revolting” by Gracie Gardner ’13, “Bodies They Ritual,” “The Headlands,” “Paris,” “The Workshop,” “Asshole,” and “Tom & Eliza.” Before moving to Ohio for high school, he grew up in France, England and Scotland with his five siblings.
Will Arbery ’11

Will Arbery is a playwright, TV/ film writer and filmmaker. He was a Pulitzer Prize finalist for “Heroes of the Fourth Turning” in 2020. His other plays include “Corsicana” starring Will Dagger ’10 (Playwrights Horizons), “Plano” (Clubbed Thumb), “Evanston Salt Costs Climbing” starring Rachel Sachnoff ’12 (The New Group 2022, New Neighborhood 2018), “Wheelchair” (3 Hole Press), “You Hateful Things” (development at The Public, SPACE on Ryder Farm, and NYTW Dartmouth Residency). He’s currently under commission from Audible, MTC and Playwrights Horizons. He was a writer and co-producer on “Succession” (HBO) and supervising producer on “Irma Vep” (HBO). He is currently developing a TV project with Fifth Season and Boku Films, and several film projects.
Japhet Balaban ’09

Japhet Balaban is an actor. He returned to Broadway this fall as part of the company of “Other Desert Cities,” starring Allison Janney ’82 H’00. Recent credits include Tom Stoppard’s “Leopoldstadt” on Broadway, Caryl Churchill’s “Glass. Kill. What If If Only. Imp” at The Public Theatre, and “Eureka Day” and “John Proctor is the Villain” at The Huntington in Boston. Other favorite credits include “Women Laughing Alone with Salad” and “You on the Moors Now,” both directed by Devon de Mayo ’01 in Chicago. Film and TV: “The Thing about Harry,” “Fargo” (FX), “Empire” (Fox), “The Chi” (Showtime), “Chicago Med” (NBC) and “Chicago PD” (NBC).
Will Dagger ’10

Will Dagger is an actor. He has helped develop new work with Ars Nova, Audible, The Civilians, Clubbed Thumb, Colt Coeur, Ensemble Studio Theatre, Manhattan Theatre Club, The New Group, New York Theatre Workshop, Primary Stages, The Public Theater and Second Stage. In 2025, he was in “Well, I’ll Let You Go” by Bubba Weiler, off-Broadway. Other recent stage credits include “Good Night And Good Luck” (Broadway), “Give Me Carmelita Tropicana” (Soho Rep), “Corsicana” by Will Arbery ’11 (Playwrights Horizons), “Uncle Vanya” (OHenry Productions), “You Don’t Have To Do Anything” (Here Arts), “The Antelope Party” (Dutch Kills), “Among The Dead” (Ma-Yi), “The Convent Of Pleasure” (Cherry Lane), and “Macbeth” (Double Feature). Film and television credits include “The Bride” (2026), “Law & Order: Special Victims Unit” (NBC), “FBI: Most Wanted” (CBS), “The Blacklist” (NBC) and “Deception” (ABC).
Gracie Gardner ’13

Gracie Gardner is a playwright. Her play “Saturn Return” (Undermain Theatre) premiered in May in Dallas. “Athena” ran at theaters in Ann Arbor and Portland, Oregon this year. Knud Adams ’09 directed “I’m Revolting” (Atlantic Theater) in 2022. Her other work includes “Panopticon” (Clubbed Thumb), “Pussy Sludge” (HERE Arts Center), “Hate Baby” (James Stevenson Prize), “Spa Play” (Bridge Residency), “Primary” (Project Playwright Award), “IndianapolisAlyssa1985 Is Getting Married” (Dixon Place), “Very Dumb Kids” (Cincinnati Conservatory of Music Commission). She’s the recipient of the American Playwriting Foundation’s Relentless Award, in addition to multiple commissions and a Tow Foundation Residency.
Julia Greer ’15

Julia Greer is an actor, writer and co-founder and co-artistic director of The Hearth theater company in New York, which she launched with Emma Miller ’15 in 2016 with an emphasis on producing works by women. Their first production was “For Annie” by Beth Hyland ’13. At Kenyon, the duo was also responsible for relaunching StageFemmes in 2011, a female theater group that had been popular in the early ’90s to the mid-2000s. They have collaborated on many plays as actor and director, respectively, including “Athena” by Gracie Gardner ’13. She also appeared in “Bed, Bath and Beyond” by Natalie Margolin ’14 (Colt Coeur, 2023). The New York Times called Greer “excellent” in “Racecar Racecar Racecar” (Hearth, 2024). This summer, Julia starred in a sold-out run of the one-woman show “Big Feelings” by Ryan Drake ’14 at the Cell Theatre in New York.
Beth Hyland ’13

Beth Hyland is a playwright and screenwriter. Her plays and musicals include “Sylvia Sylvia Sylvia” (Geffen Playhouse, Williamstown Theatre Festival), “Baby Shower Katie” (Primary Stages, Round House Theatre), “Fires, Ohio” (Alliance Theatre, Portland Center Stage, Goodman Theatre) “Cancelina” (Wagner New Play Festival), and “Seagulls” (The Sound at Steppenwolf LookOut, Octagon Theatre Bolton). She is a 2026-2027 Terrence McNally Fellow at Rattlestick Theatre and received the 2025 Alliance/Kendeda Graduate Playwriting Award and the 2024 Weissberger Prize. She currently holds commissions from Manhattan Theatre Club/Sloan, Geffen Playhouse, La Jolla Playhouse, Steppenwolf Theatre, and Williamstown Theatre Festival. She recently received her MFA in Playwriting from UC San Diego.
Natalie Margolin ’14

Natalie is a playwright, and TV and film writer. Her play, “All Nighter,” set at a small liberal arts college, concluded an off-Broadway run in 2025 at the Robert W. Wilson MCC space. In 2020, she wrote a new play specifically for Zoom during the pandemic, “The Party Hop.” (A reading of the play is available on YouTube, starring Beanie Feldstein, Ayo Edebiri, Ashley Park, Ben Platt and others.) Her first play, “The Power Of Punctuation,” premiered off-Broadway in 2016. The New York Times called it a “smart and incisive ... oasis of entertainment.” She is currently developing a television project with Lorne Michaels’ Broadway Video and Universal. She has both a television and film project in development with Mark Gordon Pictures.
Harrison David Rivers ’04

Harrison David Rivers is an award-winning playwright, librettist and TV writer based in St. Paul, Minnesota. His works include “This Bitter Earth,” “We Are Continuous,” “The Salvagers,” “The Bandaged Place,” “Where Storms Are Born,” “A Christmas Carol,” and the musicals “Last Of The Red Hot Mamas” with Sue and Lloyd Ecker, “We Shall Someday” with Ted Shen, “The Neverglades” with Benjamin Velez and “It Comes With The Building” with Jacob Yandura ’09 and Rebekah Melocik. His television credits include “One Of Us Is Lying” (Peacock), “The Nevers” (HBO) and “Wytches” (Amazon). He has developed projects with HBO and Lena Waithe’s Hillman Grad Productions and is a recipient of McKnight, Jerome and Van Lier Fellowships; residencies with the Ojai Playwrights Conference, Ground Floor at Berkeley Rep, Siena Art Institute, Geva, New York Theatre Workshop, Williamstown and Duke University; and is currently under commission from Yale Rep, MCC, Geva and Minnesota Opera.
Rachel Sachnoff ’12

Rachel Sachnoff is an actress based in New York. Most recently, she appeared in the new Netflix series “The Decameron.” She appeared in “Evanston Salt Costs Climbing” ( New Group) and “Wheelchair” (3 Hole Press) by Will Arbery ’11. She has performed in original productions with companies including New Neighborhood, Ensemble Studio Theatre, Ars Nova’s ANT Fest, Dixon Place, The Tank, Cloud City, The Wild Project, The New Ohio, Two Headed Rep, Calliope, and the Brick. Rachel has developed new theatrical work at Playwrights Horizons, Clubbed Thumb, The O’Neill, The Bushwick Starr, The New Group, The Lark, Mabou Mines, the Pittsburgh Fringe Festival and many more. She studied improv comedy at both Second City and the Upright Citizens Brigade.
Students on campus for the summer learn new lessons from a familiar, but quieter, place.
Read The StoryMatt Winkler ’77 celebrates his 50th reunion by honoring his classmates.
Read The Story