Capitol Punishment

In this presidential election year, Ohio once again figured as a crucial state. That’s also true of the fictional 2016 in Capitol Punishment (Ohio University Press), the fast-paced, witty detective novel by Andrew Welsh-Huggins ’83 P’17. If a national election is the backdrop for this story, however, the larger message is that all politics are local, and local politics can be crazy convoluted.

A veteran reporter for the Associated Press in Columbus, Welsh-Huggins knows Ohio’s capital city inside-out — and knows its history, neighborhoods, landmarks, subcultures, simmering conflicts and, yes, politics. He has deployed that knowledge with verve in a series of mysteries set in Columbus and featuring Andy Hayes, a disgraced Ohio State quarterback turned private eye.

In this, the third Andy Hayes adventure, a freelance journalist named Lee Hershey hires Hayes to protect him. From? Well, it quickly becomes apparent that Hershey is a skilled muckraker with an obnoxious, confrontational personality, and the book’s opening scenes introduce a long line of potential enemies. Those enemies turn into suspects after Hershey is found bludgeoned to death in the Ohio Statehouse, on a night when Hayes was supposed to show up to protect him — but someone has slipped a knockout drug into the private eye’s beer.

The drama quickly becomes complicated, as Hayes threads his way among legislators, staffers, lobbyists, union officials and reporters. His sleuthing takes him to the office of Ohio’s Democratic governor (remember, this is fiction), who may soon become his party’s vice presidential pick. The hot political issue around which these figures swirl is the (historically very real) problem of school funding in Ohio.

The governor has proposed a reform initiative called Fair Funding Focus. (The name provides one of the book’s running jokes, as the governor’s allies realize that FFF isn’t particularly good shorthand for an education bill but can’t get anyone to use the new name they devise, ABC.) The success of FFF is critical to the governor’s vice presidential ambitions. Everybody, from his Republican adversaries, to charter school proponents, to casino operators, has an interest in the bill. And it seems that Lee Hershey knew all of their motives and secrets.

The colorful characters in Capitol Punishment range from a wizened Statehouse tour guide whose ancestor killed a reporter, to a grumpy police lieutenant who bears an uncanny resemblance to Commodore Perry of the Battle of Lake Erie, to a state Supreme Court justice who raises a rare breed of pigs and hides a secret that could embarrass him in an upcoming election. The Statehouse itself becomes a kind of character, as Welsh-Huggins leads us through its labyrinth of hallways and chambers and up the hidden staircase to its cupola.

A second murder and two close calls heighten the suspense. And the back stories that emerge include bribery, extortion, tainted government contracts, unhappy love affairs, ugly divorces, career-ending scandals, hints of scandals yet to be revealed and political spying — in short, business as usual, if maybe a little bit intensified.

Private eye Andy Hayes observes this world with a wryness that reflects his creator’s experience with the ironies of public life. A profiteering charter-school corporation, for example, has the quaint name Little Red Schoolhouse. “The company’s website featured an actual red schoolhouse on a grassy hill. … The real headquarters [in a] seven-story glass-windowed cube … looked like the kind of place where people on headphones spent their days denying patients’ insurance coverage.”

If Capitol Punishment does little to dispel cynicism about the practice of politics, it also offers an enjoyable escape from the realities of this political year. Here, the truth comes out, and we, the readers, have fun in the process. After all, it’s fiction.

Web extra: Welsh-Huggins has written several pieces for Kenyon's blog, Acceptance Letters: Parents, college and letting go. Read more at

More Recent Books by Kenyon Authors

Emily Guy Birken '01, Making Social Security World for You: Advice, Strategies, and Timelines That Can Maximize Your Benefits

(Adams Media). A prolific finance writer who has published two previous books about retirement, Birken here offers detailed advice to “help you cut through the confusion and determine what claiming strategy will make the most sense for you.”

Eric D. Lehman '94, Shadows of Paris

(Homebound Publications). The American-in-Paris narrator of this novella finds that, if you’re lonely and wounded, the City of Light can be unbearable — but then he meets a fellow American with a tragedy in her own past, and the healing begins for both of them, with the help of French art, literature and food.

Kenneth Logan '96, True Letters from a Fictional Life

True Letters from a Fictional Life

(HarperCollins). James Liddell is a star athlete who appears to be dating a cute girl. But, in letters that he never sends, he struggles with the truth about his homosexuality. Logan’s young-adult novel is smart, realistic and thoroughly engaging.

Cameron Macauley '79, Unborn Evil: The Complete Gold Child Trilogy

Macauley’s intricate trilogy tells the story of Nhean Thavy, a Cambodian refugee from the Khmer Rouge era, and her three children. Magic and witchcraft infuse the tale, which takes its characters to the Amazon and Mozambique as well as New England. Macauley himself has worked as a Peace Corps volunteer and trauma rehabilitation specialist in war-ravaged parts of Asia, Africa and South America.

Robert B. O'Connor '79, Gumptionade: The Booster for Your Self-Improvement Plan

People with gumption “do what needs to be done ... with courage, resourcefulness and common sense.” O’Connor’s thoughtful, useful book offers a wealth of advice — and plenty of real-life examples — on how to effectively play the cards that life deals out.

Kristen Orlando '05, You Don't Know My Name

(Macmillan). Not many 16-year-olds “sleep with knives taped to their headboards or know ten different ways to break someone’s neck.” This young-adult thriller follows Reagan Elizabeth Hillis as she navigates the normal world of high school, and falling in love, while being raised to join her parents as an operative in the Black Angels, a top-secret unit of the CIA. Kenyon makes a cameo appearance as Templeton College, complete with a Middle Path.

Frank Scalambrino '98, editor, Social Epistemology and Technology: Toward Public Self-Awareness Regarding Technological Mediation

(Rowman & Littlefield). Scalambrino, a philosophy professor, has assembled a collection of scholarly essays on how technology has changed what it means to be human. Topics range from trust in the age of big data to the ethical implications of facial recognition software.

William J. Wainwright '57, Reason, Revelation, and Devotion: Inference and Argument in Religion

Reason, Revelation, and Devotion width=

(Cambridge University Press). In this short but wide-ranging book, Wainwright — an emeritus professor of philosophy — discusses the nature of religious reasoning, the “person-relativity” of religious argumentation and the limits of reason in defending religious traditions.

Also In This Edition